Thursday, January 10, 2008

Simple Way to Explain Subprime Crisis

Have you heard about subprime crisis in U.S? Do you know what is it? Do you know why it happens? This article provides a very simple explanation of subprime crisis especially for those non-financial people or economist.

It was a very hot issue that has been discussed over the last year. I tried to search around the web to get more information about this subprime crisis in U.S. but all those explanations were too difficult for me to understand. So, this article is to simplify the explanation of subprime crisis which appears to be a very complex thing. I did this on my own research based on my understanding. You can verify whether my understanding is correct or not.


What is Subprime Mortgage?

First of all, we need to understand what subprime means. By dictionary, “Subprime” is an adjective relating to or for people with a poor credit rating. Simply says, if you never clear your credit card balance monthly, you have a poor credit rating. A poor credit rating people are disqualified to apply for conventional mortgage or loan application. They’re disqualified because they have higher risks that they are not able to make the loan payment due to their poor credit history. Bank is very clever. They come out a special type of loan to these poor credit rating people. This loan or mortgage is called “Subprime Mortgage” or “Subprime Loan”.


Why Banks Want Subprime Mortgage?

Why banks (subprime lenders) want to lend money to those who have bad credit history? They may not even able to payback the bank. But still, why they want to do that? Yes, you got it. It is all related to money. The banks are also greedy and they want to earn more. The main reason why the banks want to do this is they predict the value of the property will be going up. So they increase the mortgage interest rate (higher than the conventional loan) and they call it a subprime mortgage. They earn more with the higher mortgage interest rate and just in case the borrowers can’t continue the payment, they still can sell the houses with higher value due to the property appreciation.

To further reduce the risks and to get more loans (earn more money by loan interest), the banks repackage all mortgages into an investment product and sell it to financial institutions in all over the world (not just in U.S). This is now not only between banks and borrowers get involved in this subprime mortgage but also all the financial institutions around the world. You may ask why they want to invest in this high risk product (pool of subprime mortgage)? One reason, they believe that the property value will go up.


What happen to subprime borrowers?

They buy the house only for one reason which is expecting value of the houses to go up and they earn from the property appreciation. They can rent out their house with higher value or they can sell the house with higher value. All the debts they had previously can be easily paid off. Because house prices had increased so rapidly in the past few years, paying back the loan payment is not a problem at all. The borrowers also refinance their loan at more favourable terms due to they no longer have a bad credit rating history.

Can you see that? Everybody wins! Borrowers, banks and financial institutions are eating the same cheese happily and the cheese is “property appreciation”. Yummy, yummy!

When and Why Crisis Happens?

I think you should be able to guess it by now when the crisis will happen. Everybody enjoys the same cheese, if the cheese is gone, what happen? Crisis happens. It is that simple. When the house or property values drops, the cheese is gone. Everybody wins now becomes everybody loses!

When demand is more than supply (everyone wants to buy house), the property values went up like crazy. Until one day, when it becomes much more expensive to borrow, less people could afford to buy a house. As there were not as many buyers, the real estate market begin to cool down and house prices begin to fall.

When the house prices begin to fall, the subprime borrowers are going to suffer. Not only they’re not able to pay their existing debt, they are stuck having to pay a much larger mortgage payment. This causes many of these borrowers to not be able to make their house payment.

So for the financial institutions, they are going to lose their money that they invested because the borrower are not able to pay the loan payment. On the other hand, banks have a very big problem also because they rely on this these financial institutions to invest in the pool of mortgages investment product. Financial institutions no longer wants to invest and do not trust the bank anymore. If no wants want to buy them, where the banks get the money to offer the loans?

They bank also suffer from the lost for those borrowers who failed to make payment. As a result, the banks increase the mortgage interest rate to cover loses and hopes that borrowers (who afford to pay) can pay more. Sadly, the effect is opposite and this even makes the conditions worst. More and more borrowers failed to pay their monthly loan payment due to the interest rate increases. Crisis happens! Everyone suffers!

Conclusion

Subprime crisis happens because everyone predicts the property value will appreciate over time. The economy now is no longer as simple as in 30 years ago where we can predict the future with certain of accuracy. Future is getting harder and harder to be predicted for the coming years. What it next? It is really unknown.

Therefore the impact of this crisis is still has a lot of uncertainty. Will it causes another economy recession in U.S since 2000? Will this affect other countries? This is another huge topic to be discussed. Anyway, I hope this post is making sense and give you a little bit general idea on this subprime mortgage crisis in U.S.
[Updated - 20 Jan 2008]
Check out the latest news of the effect of the subprime crisis - Citigroup loses almost $10B
To have more comprehensive of explanation (which I find it difficult to understand), you can refer to this article from wikipedia.

41 Comments:

cheerfulday said...

I din know that actually. Thanks for the info

Peky said...

Good one! :)

mariam said...

I thought this was a great write up. Easy to read and great explanation!

ChampDog said...

Hey guys! Thanks!

mz said...

thanks!! great explanation.

ChampDog said...

You're welcome! :)

Minyu2Fx said...

Gee..at last I understand. I mean I really understand now. Thanks a lot.

Sathish said...

awesome.. simple n clear..

ChampDog said...

Thanks. I"m still learning. Hope this is a good sharing. :)

A student said...

Thanks for the easy-to-read write up, certainly is better than what my lecturers at school had done.

Anonymous said...

It was a okay explanation, but your grammar made some parts a bit hard to understand. Overall it was pretty good considering it was only basic, but your wording just needed to make a bit more sense. Good job :)

ChampDog said...

Thanks for the feedback. I will try my best to make it better in my next post. Perhaps if I have time, I will then rewrite this post to make it better.

Anonymous said...

Why a U.S. centric event had degenerated into a global crisis? How about MBS and CDO craps issued by investment banks? You didn't explain that...

ChampDog said...

Thanks for the feedback. I wonder if I explained that, it will defeat the original purpose of this post.

Anonymous said...

I've found this article in the Times made it pretty clear on how a US event has had a global impact and pretty simple to follow.

http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1651865,00.html?loomia_si=t0:a3:g2:r2:c0.155049

Saurabh Raja said...

Good one... very simple and yet comprehensive analysis

suman said...

well the analysis was lucid and clear now even i can explain it o any one

Ruby said...

Thank you very much! You really have a great knowledge about economy as well as finance to what happend recently... Your post really help me very much ^_^ God bless you!

ChampDog said...

You're welcome, Ruby. :)

sayantan said...

well the post was quite good..but i had 1 question...why does the cost of borrowing increases and the price of property falls..why does that happen if everyone wants to buy a house then the demand is more than the supply..isn't it? so ain't the price ought to go up? i mean if u had thrown a bit more light on this then i being a non-economics student could have understood well!

ChampDog said...

You’re right. I think you have a point. I’m not an economic student too. Let me try to explain in a simple form see if it makes sense. There is a scientific term for this phenomena. It is called “Bubble Burst”.

If the house price keeps going up and up again until certain limit will you still buy? Or there is no limit? Think about it. Let’s say the house value increases from $100K to $500K. Okay you probably still believe it will still go up. What about from $100K to $1 Million? Will you still buy? There is one point you will think that “It is just too expensive”. Once you stop buying and everyone does the same, demand will than less than supply, the house prices start dropping. When the house price is dropping, will you dare to buy? So if everyone does not dare to buy, then the house prices will be dropped dramatically.

Hopefully this is clear. This explains why it drops. This happens usually due to speculation for example. The actual price of the house is way below the market price. What you see the price in the market now is not the real one. The amount of supply & demand amount is also not really the real one. That is why crisis happen and no one really can predict when it will happen. The worlds is too complex, it is not just you and me. Therefore no one can really think the crisis will happen that soon and still enjoying the cheese.

Does my explanation make sense to you? I hope it does help. It is more like sharing and discussion purpose. Thanks for the question and comment.

sekartunjung said...

Oh i really enjoyed your explanation thank you for sharing about this topic.

ChampDog said...

You're welcome! I"m still a learning student. :)

vishwas shenoy said...

Thank You very much. I really understood a lot about the confusing terms. Keep going

mohit said...

Wonderfully explaied. Great job man.

kk said...

that was a good explanation!!! simply superb...

Anonymous said...

that was brillantly explained..but i want to know more about the relation between financial institutions and banks...

arnab datta said...

hope to c more such articles later...
nice one...

Horlic said...

Thanks for the simple explanation on the subprime crisis.

ChampDog said...

Good question! I think to operate as a bank, you need the full banking license. The one without the full banking license is called "financial institution".

They're basically similar as long as company that take and manage deposit and make loans, you can call the financial institution (e.g. investment fund company, and insurance company).

I hope I'm right.

Anonymous said...

Thanks a lot dude, the article was excellent, marvellous!!!!

Anonymous said...

yes this explanation is really gud for non-financial person like me........thnx a lot

Anonymous said...

U R simply great, great people make things look simple

Rupali D. said...

I was Knowing it But it made much clear in exact manner I just want to confirm it. So Simple to understand. Thanks

Anonymous said...

Great write-up and very simple to understand. Thanks aton

akshada said...

It was gr8!!
Thanks a lot.

mayank said...

Good effort dude but ur explanation was incorrect as it were the financial institutions who started the process of lending money to the subprine borrowers and not the banks.There were 4 players involved:
1. Financial Institutions
2. Sub prime Borrowers
3. Banks
4. Institutional Investors.

mayank said...

It was a very intertwined game from the financial institutions who manipulated the incomes of the subprime borrowers to get more money to lend to the subprime borrowers from the banks and in turn also to earn form securitisation of the asstes.For more details u can always mail me to mynkjindal1983@yahoo.co.in
I will be happy to address ur queries.

ChampDog said...

mayank, thanks for your honest comment. I thought it all started with the bank and later on the repackage as investment products to those those financial institutions. I hope I'm right.

Perhaps, you can help to explain in more detail how it was all started with those financial institutions? and how it was then linked to bank?

But, do we really want to know who started this first? Is is important? I will still bet the bank started all these. But who are the banks? Government? So, the governments started all these?

Anonymous said...

amazingly helpful!

ruchi said...

very nicely explained,
was preparing a related topic for my presentation and got indepth knowledge of it.


Didn't find what you want? Use Google Search Engine below: